continued from page two...

Why were the exterminated troops left there? Was it because of linger­ing contamination, or as a message? If so, to whom? The Americans openly discussed the possibility of using an Atom Bomb to turn the tide of events in Korea. Was this supposed to be a deterrent? Use an atom bomb and here is how we will retaliate?

Assuming the bodies were in place for 21 days or longer, it is incom­prehensible to think that no one else stumbled across our grisly discovery. During this time, across the central front, UN forces were mounting daily patrols. What other patrols penetrated this area and what other intelligence was gleaned? What aerial photography captured the land­scape? What of the daily aerial flights of a variety of spotter aircraft flying over no-mans-land at relatively low altitudes? It is an irrefutable fact that on May 21, 1951, UN forces took the offensive, ultimately retaking not only this area but all the lands given up to the enemy and more. I can find no explanation. Who disposed of the bodies? Why, 50 years on, would an innocent nation refuse to reveal acts of enemy aggression? Assuming the Russians were experimenting with this type of genocide, had democratic forces deemed it necessary to demonstrate conclusively that others were not above retaliation? This incident is a double-edged sword that both confounds and menaces the intellect. Yet somewhere, the answer lies in some secret archive.

Was it a coincidence that the only means of communication I had on that patrol was an American Walkie Talkie? We were too distant to make contact with our company headquarters. The American tanks, three hours to the south, were too far away and unfortunately did not have the equipment to receive our wireless communications. Were we to carry casualties out on our backs? There were no means of periodic situation reports. Were we operating under an enforced silence? Did some experimental intelligence group, knowing full well what we would discover, want to find out if the contaminates were still active? Perhaps we were truly earning our nickname of being labeled the "PBI," The Poor Bloody Infantry.

Thank God, we are fortunate enough to live in a civilized nation where one questions how men could possibly commit such horrific crimes. At Los Alamos, the atomic bomb experiments inflicted cancer from radiation upon the American and Canadian troops who volunteered, despite the fact they were reassured that they were perfectly safe. The final incident involved placing the troops within a mile of the detonation point where they were ordered to advance to prepared slit trenches. There were none. The men were radiated while lying on top of the open ground and it was years before the two governments finally admitted their responsibility. Similar experiments were conducted injecting LSD, at the direction of governments. For years they were denied their unfortunate "guinea-pigs" status. For some, compensation came decades later. During the Second World War, Canada subjected soldiers to live Mustard Gas experiments at Suffield Military Establishment. One cannot but wonder what other undisclosed and irresponsible actions may have been committed, or are being committed, in the name of the defence of a nation.

The United Kingdom Korean War Veterans newsletter, The Morning Calm, published my report of our 1951 patrol in April of 1999. The magazine later received a letter from a UK Korean veteran, Derek Bennett, formerly a Field Linesman, Royal Corps of Signals, with the 27th Brigade. Bennett and a chap named Price reported finding 25 to 30 North Korean troops, lying down as if resting in a field about 100 yards from a road. They were attired in the usual white winter parkas, having a red star on their headgear. They were all dead and they could not find a point of penetration on any of the bodies. The book, "Rangers in Korea," by Robert Black, on page 190 cites a similar incident. They found an entire village with people in positions reflecting their carrying out a variety of chores - all unexplainably dead. "Men hardened by the many faces of death wiped tears from their eyes and hastened from the valley.”3
           
                                   
  This lingering threat begs haunting questions:

It would be convenient for a government, intent upon implying it was the other antagonist, to indifferently annihilate their own, or prisoners of war, in the midst of no-mans-land. Why was this "incident" undertaken? Who possessed the "creative" know how?

 For what future purpose?  
and  
Why was my written report suppressed?

1.   Edicott & Hagerman, page 63. Also see: MBC -South Korean Documen­tary, "The US Biological Warfare in Korea," http:/www.imbc.com.sisa -and - doc/nowtell/htm/vod/vod 000702.htm

2.   Stone in an interview with LCol GWLNicholson, D. History, Army Head­quarters, 1630 hrs, 5 June 195 1, stated that he was receiving sufficient rein­forcements in Korea. I find this curious for in my experience we were always well short of establishment numbers for soldiers.

3.   Black: Ballantine Publishing Company, (Random House) 1989

 WITNESS STATEMENTS

 12 Platoon Patrol - Mass Execution-Gumcochyi Patrol, May 1951

I find it difficult to remember much about the details of this patrol, though a few points stand out in my memory.

Our platoon commander was Lt. Gray. The whole platoon went on this patrol. It seemed to me we went an awfully long way out in front our battalion position. It was a hot day we were still wearing our winter uniforms.

I remember clearly... enemy soldiers all in three lines... Like a platoon. There were a lot of them. All dead. They were in a sort of sitting position, rigidly upright, all of them. It was not natural. What I remember most was the awful stench of death. I did not like it. I remember circling a long way out from them, because I could not stand the smell.

James Wanniandy  
131104 15411 87th Avenue  
Edmonton
, Alberta , T5R 4K3  
February 28th, 1998
.

 To Whom it May Concern - 98 02 12

 Statement of Pte (S/Sgt) George Nestor  
"Gumcochyi" Patrol , Korea , May 1951  
Lt. Hub Gray, 12 PI, "D" Coy 2nd Bn PPCLI

I was a member of 12 Platoon, but at the time was attached to "D" Company HQ, as runner. I was made aware of the patrol the day prior when the order came down to Capt Mills. Capt Mills was in command in the absence of Major Swinton, who was in charge of the Brigade NCO School.

I have read the report, written by Hub Gray, of the "Gumcochyi" patrol, made by 12 Platoon, "D " Company, during the first half of May 1951. I concur that the contents of the report are essentially as I remember it.

Captain Mills selected 12 to make the patrol. Being aware of the patrol, I was present the next morning when the platoon boarded tanks of the American 73rd Heavy Tank Battalion. I went to wish my buddies luck.

The information brought back at the end of the day was a hell of a surprise to all of us. They had found a whole platoon of enemy soldiers dead in some sort of mass formation. The information caused one hell of a buzz amongst us because of the queer way in which they all died at one time, on their knees sifting on their haunches. Gray wrote a re­port for Mills, saying he believed they died from some form of chemical warfare. That report caused a lot of concern - was it going to happen to us - when? We expected that there would be another patrol to further investigate the whole thing, but nothing happened. After a week, it faded away; we were preparing to move off of Line Golden, in pursuit of the enemy.

George Nestor                                       
6033 Camass Place  
Duncan
, BC, V9L 3ZI

 Statement - Pte (Sgt) C. (Neil) Neufeld

"Gumcochyi"
Patrol , Korea , May 1951.

We were on Golden Line, when 12 Platoon took this patrol. I remem­ber we were happy to be given a ride on the American Tanks, instead of walking all those miles in front of our position. The weather was very hot; we still had our winter gear on. The tanks pulled in just after breakfast, if that's what you can call "C" rations.

Someone put their foot on the exhaust pipe and in a few seconds dam near burnt the bottom of their boot off. Best Hot Foot I have ever seen.  

At Gumcochyi the tanks parked and our patrol took off on foot. We were to find where the enemy had dug in. Hub Gray took a photograph of my section moving off along the railroad tracks, with the smashed up rail station behind us. I was fourth in the photo, carrying my Bren Gun, and two hundred rounds of ammunition. We were about two hours out when we sighted the enemy.

After pausing to examining the lay of the land, Lt Gray sent my section onto the right flank to give covering fire while the other two sections moved forward in an attack formation. The enemy formation was in the middle of a broad valley. There was no firing. The enemy troops were in line like an oversized platoon. All dead, sitting upright. Bloody peculiar, I thought. The men talked about these enemies dead for some­time afterward.

I saw a lot of strange things in Korea, this just added one more event to my war. To me it was all part of 'another days work.

 Neil Neufeld
Apt.A l0l   8620 Jasper Avenue, Edmonton AB

 

Hub Gray served in the 2nd Battalion, Princess Patricia’s Canadian Light Infantry from October 1950 - May 1953.  He joined Richardson Securities of Canada in 1953, served in Partner Research, Partner Europe and Middle East and Partner Alberta , 1975.  He became an independent business consultant in 1978 and retired in 1995.  He and his wife, Pamela Joy live in Calgary , Alberta .

Hub Gray’s book, Beyond the Danger Close is available from Bunker to Bunker Books, 1428 - 9 Ave SE, Calgary , AB , T2T 5J4 .  Tel (403) 264 8342.  $24.95 plus $6 shipping and handling.

 

Home

Story Archives